Man loses 5th Amendment appeal after forced to unlock phone with fingerprint

Man loses 5th Amendment appeal after forced to unlock phone with fingerprint

The Fifth Amendment protects individuals from incriminating themselves, but a Minnesota court has ruled it does not apply when a suspect is ordered to provide a fingerprint to unlock a cell phone.

Giving a fingerprint is akin to standing in a lineup, not revealing a password, the Minnesota Court of Appeals found on Tuesday.

The three-judge panel ruled against Matthew Vaughn Diamond, who was convicted in 2015 of theft, burglary and criminal damage to property after the Carver County District Court threatened to hold him in contempt if he refused to offer his fingerprint to unlock his cell phone. Incriminating evidence was subsequently discovered on the device. The phone had been the subject of a search warrant.

#FBI facing FOIA requests over hacking of San Bernardino terrorist iPhone https://t.co/VgDqxtQONkpic.twitter.com/CoAyhH6LxV

— RT America (@RT_America) September 17, 2016

“Diamond was not required to disclose any knowledge he might have or to speak his guilt,” Judge Tracy Smith wrote in the court’s opinion, adding, “The district court’s order is therefore distinguishable from requiring a defendant to decrypt a hard drive or produce a combination.”

Smith cited Supreme Court precedent in the 1988 case Doe v. United States, where the high court wrote, “in order to be testimonial, [a criminal defendant’s] communication must itself, explicitly or implicitly, relate a factual assertion or disclose information. Only then is a person compelled to be a ‘witness’ against himself.”

A 2010 federal case, United States v. Kirschner, resulted in a ruling that found requiring a defendant to supply a computer password did, in fact, violate the Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination.

“[T]he task that Diamond was compelled to perform—to provide his fingerprint—is no more testimonial than furnishing a blood sample, providing handwriting or voice exemplars, standing in a lineup, or wearing particular clothing,” Smith wrote in Tuesday’s decision.

“We express no opinion regarding whether, in a given case, a defendant may be compelled to produce a cellphone password, consistent with the Fifth Amendment,” she continued.

Diamond has been sentenced to 51 months in prison.

Court ruling a crushing blow to cell phone privacy - privacy advocates [VIDEO] https:[email protected][email protected]_RT

— RT America (@RT_America) June 1, 2016



Add Comment

all comments

  Other news

more
Carmarthenshire mum-to-be gets armed escort to hospital

Carmarthenshire mum-to-be gets armed escort to hospital..

29-May, 12:00

Armed officers who spotted a speeding car in west Wales discovered a...

US lawmakers seek to reverse Trump’s $110bn arms deal with Saudi Arabia

US lawmakers seek to reverse Trump’s $110bn arms deal with Saudi Arabia..

29-May, 07:48

Top Republicans and Democrats in Congress have called for the...

Emmerdale's Lucy Pargeter introduces twin baby daughters Missy Mabel and Betsey Maggie and reveals terrifying moment at birth when babies 'weren't breathing'

Emmerdale's Lucy Pargeter introduces twin baby daughters Missy Mabel and Betsey Maggie and..

29-May, 11:24

In an exclusive shoot and interview with OK! Magazine, Lucy Pargeter...

Improving wheat yields by increasing grain size, weight

Improving wheat yields by increasing grain size, weight..

29-May, 11:48

Larger, heavier wheat kernels -- that's how associate professor Wanlong...

Former Hillary Clinton aide writing memoir

Former Hillary Clinton aide writing memoir..

19-Apr, 18:16

A former Hillary Clinton aide and speechwriter is writing a book about...

Marathon Oil and Community Health skid; MoneyGram soars

Marathon Oil and Community Health skid; MoneyGram soars..

14-Mar, 17:18

Stocks that moved substantially or traded heavily on Tuesday: MoneyGram...

Seoul: North Korea fires ballistic missile off east coast

Seoul: North Korea fires ballistic missile off east coast..

04-Apr, 19:24

South Korea says North Korea has fired a ballistic missile into the...

O'Reilly apologizes for jest about Maxine Waters' hair

O'Reilly apologizes for jest about Maxine Waters' hair..

29-Mar, 09:40

Fox News personality Bill O'Reilly apologized Tuesday for saying he had a...