MLB drops the ball in ruling Mexico out of the World Baseball Classic

MLB drops the ball in ruling Mexico out of the World Baseball Classic


MLB drops the ball in ruling Mexico out of the World Baseball Classic

It is heartbreaking to lose out based on a hundredth of a run. It is infuriating to lose out when your team has been told something entirely different in advance, as Mexican team officials insisted they had before Sunday’s game.

We all had. On the television network run by MLB, and on the website run by MLB, each promoting the tournament run by MLB, the message was the same: If Mexico wins by two runs, Mexico advances.

Mexico won by two.

But wait, this postgame interpretation just in from the rules committee: That five-run inning earlier in the week, in which Italy walked off? Mexico did not get an out, so that did not count as an inning. The five runs still counted.

If it would have counted as an inning, Mexico would have advanced. The rule specifies that partial innings count.

“The rule doesn't specify outs,” Mexico Manager Edgar Gonzalez told reporters after the game. “It specifies partial innings. And if you go to a judge, this is a partial inning.”

Mexico has not sued, as far as we know. The Mexicans filed a protest, and lost.

Dodgers first baseman Adrian Gonzalez, the brother of the Mexican manager, on Monday tweeted a picture of a dictionary definition of “partial,” then directed another tweet to MLB chief baseball officer Joe Torre: “Looks like some rules makers cannot go by their own rules.”

If the tournament were run in the manner of boxing, there would be no question that Mexico would have advanced. The best interests of the WBC demanded it, and the rules would have been interpreted accordingly.

Sell tickets to an Italy-Venezuela tiebreaker game in Mexico, rather than include Mexico in the game? Good luck with that.

Keep hope alive that Mexico could play in San Diego, rather than Italy or Venezuela? Let the WBC tie another hand behind its back in trying to popularize the tournament.

It is not as if Mexico would have advanced without winning a game. It is not as if Mexico is solely a gate attraction rather than a decent baseball team.

There would have been nothing outrageous about making sure Mexico played Monday. Mexico deserved it, and so did the WBC.



Add Comment

all comments

  Other news

more
Future of beach warfare: US Marines test ‘HyperSub,’ machine-gun toting robots & more (VIDEOS)

Future of beach warfare: US Marines test ‘HyperSub,’ machine-gun toting robots & more (VIDEOS)..

28-Apr, 06:48

Around 50 advanced weapons are being tested by the US Marine Corps, from...

Report Fox sex settlement probe expands to second agency, report says

Report Fox sex settlement probe expands to second agency, report says..

28-Apr, 11:16

Roger Ailes attends the Carnegie Hall 125th Season Opening Night Gala at...

Michelle Obama: 'I won't run for office' for my children

Michelle Obama: 'I won't run for office' for my children..

28-Apr, 13:56

Former First Lady Michelle Obama appeared to rule out running for elected...

Judge won't hear gay adoptions because it's not in a child's 'best interest'

Judge won't hear gay adoptions because it's not in a child's 'best interest'..

28-Apr, 15:57

A family court judge who sits in Barren and Metcalfe counties has...

Pence tells European allies US 'strongly supports' NATO and will be 'unwavering' in its commitment to the alliance

Pence tells European allies US 'strongly supports' NATO and will be 'unwavering' in its..

18-Feb, 04:04

Pence tells European allies US 'strongly supports' NATO and will be...

Chinese firm ZTE pleads guilty to breaking Iran sanctions

Chinese firm ZTE pleads guilty to breaking Iran sanctions..

07-Mar, 11:54

Chinese cellphone equipment maker ZTE Corp. has agreed to plead guilty...

HHS Secretary Tom Price won't guarantee new health care plan would cover all Americans

HHS Secretary Tom Price won't guarantee new health care plan would cover all Americans..

08-Mar, 07:44

Dr. Tom Price, secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services,...

Want to Be a Scientist? Maybe You Better Learn Chinese

Want to Be a Scientist? Maybe You Better Learn Chinese..

07-Mar, 07:42

Alexis Carulli is one of those terribly bright grad students in...