Pakistan Cracks Down on 'Blasphemous' Social Media Content
Pakistani students of Islamic seminaries chant slogans during a rally in support of blasphemy laws, in Islamabad, Pakistan, March 8, 2017. Hundreds of students rallied in the Pakistani capital, urging government to remove blasphemous content from social m
Pakistan is cracking down on "blasphemous" content on social media, with Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif urging swift punishment for those involved in "a nefarious conspiracy" against the country's Muslim majority.
But critics claim the real goal is silencing dissent that has flourished online about everything from politics and the military to freedom of speech and women's rights. Being labeled as "blasphemous" in Pakistan can make a person the target of violence.
The crackdown has caused concern, particularly after five bloggers critical of the government vanished in January. When they re-emerged, clearly shaken, they refused to talk about what had happened to them amid speculation they were kidnapped and tortured by Pakistan's powerful military intelligence service.
Living in the Netherlands, one said he felt he could never return to Pakistan after being called a blasphemer by a TV host.
WATCH: Pakistan Cracking Down on 'Blasphemous' Social Media
"All relevant institutions should trace the perpetrators behind such content and ensure they are handed out strict punishment in accordance with the law," Sharif's tweet said. "Love and affection of the Holy Prophet is the most precious asset for every Muslim."
Effort to silence seen
Advocates of free speech in Pakistan think the government is trying to shut up its critics.
Osama Khilji, an internet freedom activist, said the government and the court seemed unable to deal with specific social media outlets and that the court order had created fear among users of all such platforms.
"Blasphemy is a tag and a label to silence critical views, since the government knows it is a tool that can stifle voices," he told VOA's Deewa service.
"Political dissent occupies a genuine space in democratic societies and is thus encouraged and not discouraged," added Haroon Baloch, an Islamabad-based social media activist. "Such restrictions on social media create an atmosphere of fear, and this is what we see being done in Pakistan."
The crackdown also is leading to questions about what's blasphemous and what isn't, and whether the government might be behind any of the hundreds of pro-administration voices on Facebook and Twitter that blast dissidents and neighboring Afghanistan and India.
FILE - The mother of slain Pakistani social media star Qandeel Baloch mourns beside her dead body in Shah Sadderuddin, Pakistan, July 18, 2016. Baloch was killed by her brother for what he called “intolerable” behavior.
"I think in presence of stringent laws, no one would do anything deliberately that might fall under the definition of blasphemous content," rights activist Mehdi Hassan told VOA's Urdu service. "The new order is a matter of concern as blasphemy is a hugely sensitive issue in Pakistan, where even unproven allegations can provoke beatings and mob violence."
Salman Taseer, the liberal governor of the country's largest province, was killed six years ago by his own security guard, Mumtaz Qadri, after voicing support for amending Pakistan's already stringent blasphemy laws.
Qadri was hanged after being convicted of murder, but an estimated 100,000 people attended his funeral, and his gravesite has become a shrine for conservatives who believe he gave his life for Islam's Prophet Muhammad. A mosque is under construction alongside the site.
FILE - Pakistani women mourn the death of a family member during a funeral in Karachi, Pakistan, Jan. 18, 2013. The shooting death of Shahzeb Khan, 20, in one of Karachi's most upscale neighborhoods highlighted a growing trend of citizens using social media to hold the country's rich and powerful to account.
A critical issue is how far the government will go.
"The government has to make sure that our civil liberties are not compromised," said Sadaf Khan, a digital rights activist. "The internet is being seen globally as a fundamental right. And anything that restricts access to the internet and restricts access to social media basically puts our people at a disadvantage. They won't be able to compete in the global market."
Khan, director of the nonprofit Media Matters for Pakistan group, added, "We have to ensure that the other activities of political speech are not affected. It is an era of digital technology. [If] the government bans or restricts access to the social media, our people, and particularly our youth, will be isolated."
Add Commentall comments
Ozzy and Sharon Osbourne have exclusively shared pictures of their...
As the Manchester Arena bombing investigation unfolds, police raid a...
The UK's largest airline British Airways (BA) says it is working to...
Monday marks the first day that newly confirmed Supreme Court Justice...
Prince Harry paid tribute to his late mother, Diana Princess of Wales, in...