How Disney Subtly Made ‘Beauty And The Beast’ More Feminist

How Disney Subtly Made ‘Beauty And The Beast’ More Feminist

A tale of two Belles: 1991 and 2017.
660 [/url] [url=#]

Disney princess predecessors, Belle was a revelation. She wasn’t asleep for 75 percent of a story that centered around her (”Sleeping Beauty”). She did more than dress up for a ball (”Cinderella”) and unintentionally threaten other women with her beauty (”Snow White”). And she didn’t have to woo a man while physically stripped of her voice (”The Little Mermaid”). Belle, with her interest in learning and reading, and her lack of interest in being married off to a walking caricature of toxic masculinity, presented a portrait of a more empowered Disney princess.  

The latest iteration of the 18th-century fairy tale is the live-action “Beauty and the Beast” starring Emma Watson, which came out over the weekend with a record-breaking $170 million in ticket sales. It’s delightful to watch, complete with stunning visuals, splashy musical numbers and a subtle but refreshingly feminist update.


Feminists have long grappled with the contradictory forces that are at play in the 1991 Disney film. On the one hand, Belle maintains a strong sense of self throughout the movie. She has a passion for books. She is defiant in the face of men who want to make decisions for her. She is fiercely loyal to her father. She wants adventure “much more than this provincial life.” On the other hand, she falls in love with a literal animal who initially tells her that she must remain his prisoner forever.

Over the years, the movie has received strong criticism for romanticizing Stockholm Syndrome and sending a message to young girls that it is their job to tame the male “beasts” in their lives. The 2017 version of “Beauty and the Beast” had to contend with this critique before it was even released, with Emma Watson pushing back on it in a February interview with Entertainment Weekly.

“It’s something I really grappled with at the beginning; the kind of Stockholm Syndrome question about this story,” she said. “That’s where a prisoner will take on the characteristics of and fall in love with the captor. Belle actively argues and disagrees with [Beast] constantly. She has none of the characteristics of someone with Stockholm Syndrome because she keeps her independence, she keeps her independence of mind.”

The new film goes to great lengths to demonstrate Belle’s agency in every part of the story, amplifying things that are only subtly touched on in the animated version, and in some cases, creating totally new pieces of plot.

In the 1991 film, Belle is an avid reader. In the 2017 version, she wants to pass that skill and passion along to other girls. (At one point in the film, she attempts to teach a young girl in town to read and is reprimanded by the older male schoolmaster.) And to make it even clearer that Belle’s mind  - not her pretty face - is her greatest asset, the film turns her into an inventor. She is shown doing the laundry with a contraption she invented herself, sort of a horse-powered precursor to the washing machine. 

The movie also makes a point to highlight her romantic agency. Belle rejects the overtures of town cad Gaston even more clearly in 2017 than she did in 1991, telling him flat-out that they could never ever make each other happy and that she will never marry him.  

And when it comes to the slow burn romance between Belle and the Beast, the film at least attempts to offer a better explanation for their eventual amorous connection - and attempts to make it clear that Belle never accepts her fate as a permanent prisoner. She swears to her father that she will escape from the Beast’s castle when she forces him to to trade spots with her. On her first night in the castle, she begins constructing a long chain made of dresses, implying that she might use it in the future to scale her way out of the castle. 

Later on, rather than simply justifying Belle and Beast’s romantic bond with one life-saving incident, a few snowballs and a few books (though all of those elements are present in the new movie), the updated version leaves more room for their affection to grow. They discuss Shakespeare and King Arthur. They briefly travel to Paris through an enchanted book and learn about the fate of Belle’s mother - a character whose existence is ignored in the animated movie. The resulting emotional intimacy bolsters the argument that the Beast has earned Belle’s eventual love. 

As an added bonus, the side characters, both women and men, are fleshed out in ways that add to the stakes of the story. The audience is not just invested in Belle and her quest for love, understanding and adventure. We also feel for the other inhabitants of the cursed castle. The family film also highlights (albeit subtly) an openly gay character, Le Fou, and includes two prominent interracial couples - Lumiere (Ewan McGregor) and Plumette (Gugu Mbatha-Raw), and Madame Garderobe (Audra McDonald) and new character Maestro Cadenza (Stanley Tucci). 

Interestingly, despite its shortcomings, “Beauty and the Beast” has always included elements of feminist commentary - even in its earliest iterations. The fairy tale was first published in 1740 by Gabrielle-Suzanne Barbot de Villeneuve, and then revised and republished in 1756 by Jeanne-Marie Leprince de Beaumont. Even the earliest version of story - which contains many narrative elements that the 1991 animated film does not - pushed back on the notion that women must be resigned to a marital partner of their father’s choosing, something that was common practice in 18th-century France.

This theme of ownership over one’s life choices comes through quite strongly in the 1991 film. 

As French professor Paul Young told Time of the story’s 18th-century context: “[’Beauty and the Beast’ is] a story written and published by a woman, with a strong female character at its lead, who is very reflective and intelligent and she makes her own choices, which is not something you saw in French literature or in French society at the time.”

Of course, there will always be limits to the progressive messaging of a story that involves a woman falling in love with a man who begins as her captor. But in 2017, the “tale as old as time” manages to strike a balance between the warmth of nostalgia and the importance of feminist progress. So, Disney, if you’re thinking of giving feminist updates to more of the classics... Be Our Guest!


Related...
The Dark, Twisted Fairy Tales 'Beauty And The Beast' Is Based On Coming To Terms With 'Beauty And The Beast' And The Imperfect Feminism Of Disney
Suggest a correction
Emma Gray [url=http://twitter.com/emmaladyrose]

Executive Women's Editor, The Huffington Post



Add Comment

all comments

  Other news

more
Brexit: UK and EU still split on citizens' rights

Brexit: UK and EU still split on citizens' rights..

25-Jul, 10:00

Brexit Secretary David Davis has said there is a "moral imperative" to...

Trump blasts AG over 'Clinton collusion with Ukraine', says acting FBI director got '$700k from H'

Trump blasts AG over 'Clinton collusion with Ukraine', says acting FBI director got '$700k..

25-Jul, 09:00

Donald Trump has accused his attorney general of taking a "very weak...

Dermot O'Leary posts tribute to cat, Silver, following his death

Dermot O'Leary posts tribute to cat, Silver, following his death..

25-Jul, 08:40

VIEW GALLERY Dermot's pet cat has passed away Dermot captioned the...

Geordie Shore’s Marnie Simpson finally forgives 'enemy' Vicky Pattison – as she congratulates her on her engagement to John Noble: ‘Everyone deserves happiness’

Geordie Shore’s Marnie Simpson finally forgives 'enemy' Vicky Pattison – as she congratulates..

25-Jul, 16:40

Marnie opened up on their turbulent relationship in her new book Stripped...

Dubai online retailer Souq.com says sale to Amazon completed

Dubai online retailer Souq.com says sale to Amazon completed..

03-Jul, 04:48

Dubai-based Souq.com, the Middle East's biggest online retailer, says its...

Bill Cosby accuser Andrea Constand testifies

Bill Cosby accuser Andrea Constand testifies..

06-Jun, 15:48

Andrea Constand, who has accused Bill Cosby of drugging and sexually...

IS galvanized in Asia by Philippine city siege, report says

IS galvanized in Asia by Philippine city siege, report says..

21-Jul, 03:20

The attack by Islamic State group-affiliated militants on a Philippine...

Polish EU lawmaker says women intellectually inferior to men

Polish EU lawmaker says women intellectually inferior to men..

03-Mar, 11:00

A radical Polish European Parliament lawmaker has launched another sexist...