Social media firms faces huge hate speech fines in Germany

Social media firms faces huge hate speech fines in Germany

German ministers have approved plans to fine social media firms up to 50m euros ($53.3m; ?42.7m) if they fail to remove hate speech and fake news quickly.

The proposed law would give the companies 24 hours to block obviously criminal content after it had been reported, and seven days for other offensive material.

However, a plan to state explicitly that penalties could be imposed after a single infraction has been dropped.

Facebook has voiced concern.

"We work very hard to remove illegal content from our platform and are determined to work with others to solve this problem," a spokeswoman told the BBC.


"As experts have pointed out, this legislation would force private companies rather than the courts to become the judges of what is illegal in Germany."

Twitter, Snapchat and Google have yet to comment.

Germany's justice minister said hate speech posed a grave danger to harmonious living in a free, open and democratic society.

"Twitter only removes 1% of these hate speeches, Facebook removes less than 50%," said Heiko Maas.

"But we know this is possible, because YouTube manages to remove 99% of them.

"The freedom of speech is only limited by the law."

Racism and hate speech are believed to have become more prevalent on German social media following the arrival of large number of refugees in the country.

The draft law was unveiled last month. Since then, it has been amended to add child abuse imagery as a category requiring a rapid response, as well as to acknowledge that the fining authority must be careful not to undermine freedom of speech.

But a local tech lobby group, Bitkom, is concerned that social media platforms will feel compelled to err in favour of censorship.

"Given the short deadlines and the severe penalties, providers will be forced to delete doubtful statements as a precaution," said the group's manager, Bernhard Rohleder.

"That would have a serious impact on free speech on the internet."



Add Comment

all comments

  Other news

more
Made In Chelsea's Alex Mytton cosies up to his ex Nicola Hughes less than a month after his split from Lottie Moss

Made In Chelsea's Alex Mytton cosies up to his ex Nicola Hughes less than a month after his..

18-Aug, 06:40

The Made In Chelsea pair were spotted flirting at the Look Of The Day...

5 things we learned from Drew Barrymore’s interview with Millie Bobby Brown

5 things we learned from Drew Barrymore’s interview with Millie Bobby Brown..

18-Aug, 05:41

VIEW GALLERY Millie covers Teen Vogue’s Vol. III edition [h3]Millie has...

BBC Radio 4 to launch female-led panel show

BBC Radio 4 to launch female-led panel show..

17-Aug, 16:40

The BBC is to launch a topical radio panel show where the host and most...

Indian rape victim, 10, and her baby 'doing fine'

Indian rape victim, 10, and her baby 'doing fine'..

18-Aug, 07:21

A 10-year-old Indian rape victim and the baby girl she gave birth to are...

Sessions used political funds for RNC convention expenses

Sessions used political funds for RNC convention expenses..

03-Mar, 00:13

While at the Republican National Convention in Cleveland in August,...

Rumor Spreads on Facebook Users' Contacts

Rumor Spreads on Facebook Users' Contacts..

04-Mar, 20:16

Facebook has been forced to fight a rumor currently circulating on --...

Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences apologizes for Oscars mix-up

Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences apologizes for Oscars mix-up..

28-Feb, 03:28

Everybody's talking about Sunday's Oscars gaffe during which Warren...

UN food program head warns of US budget cuts amid famine

UN food program head warns of US budget cuts amid famine..

03-Apr, 23:36

The outgoing head of the United Nations' World Food Program said Monday...