Bank regulator faults itself for missing Wells Fargo issues

The nation's big bank regulator is faulting itself for failing to address the problems at Wells Fargo before it was too late.

The inspector general at the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency said Wednesday that the regulator's examiners saw sales problems at Wells Fargo as early as 2010. A scathing assessment released last week by the board of directors of the San Francisco-based bank also said the problems stretched back many years.

According to the OCC's report, examiners met with Carrie Tolstedt, the executive in charge of Wells Fargo's consumer banking operations, to discuss 700 whistleblower complaints regarding the bank's aggressive sales practices. Tolstedt told regulators at the time that the large number of complaints was due to Wells Fargo having a culture that "encourages valid complaints which are then investigated and appropriately addressed," according to the report.

Despite knowing about these complaints and other issues, the OCC declined to investigate further. It also did not look into risks that could come from compensation programs like those at Wells. The OCC's examiners took no action against Wells Fargo through at least 2014, according to the report, which would have been months after The Los Angeles Times published its investigation into Wells' sales practices in Southern California.

"The OCC did not take timely and effective supervisory actions after the bank and the OCC identified significant issues with ... sales practices," the OCC's Inspector General said in its report.

Eventually the OCC, along with other authorities, fined Wells Fargo $185 million in September, finding that Wells employees had opened as many as 2 million accounts without getting customers' permission as employees tried to meet sales goals.

Wells Fargo was known in banking circles as a having an extremely aggressive sales culture, and its executives highlighted its "cross-sell ratio," or the number of accounts or other services a Wells Fargo customer typically had at the bank. Wells was aiming for as many as eight per household, while most big banks aim to have two to three per customer.

The Inspector General's report notes that the OCC's examiners were aware of Wells' now infamous "Going for Gr-Eight" sales program, but again, did not take action.

"We are aware of no assessment of the risks and controls associated with the corporate goal of cross-selling eight products per household," OCC examiners wrote in 2010, according to the report.

The assessment by the bank's own board said the problems date back at least 15 years — but that executives had little interest in dealing with the issue until it spiraled out of control. The board has reclaimed millions in pay from Tolstedt and former CEO John Stumpf, saying they dragged their feet for years.

Tolstedt retired from Wells Fargo in June 2016. The board of directors' report laid most of the blame for Wells' toxic sales practices at her and Stumpf's feet. Tolstedt has denied the board's allegations.

Since the scandal, Wells got rid of its sales goals and restructured how it pays employees to focus less on opening checking accounts and more on how those bank accounts are actually used. The bank also stopped referring to its branches as "stores."

The bank still faces other investigations by state and federal authorities. The bank will also face angry shareholders next week at its annual meeting, amid a push to get rid of the company's board of directors.



Add Comment

all comments

  Other news

more
Bill Gates reduces Microsoft stake with $4.6bn donation

Bill Gates reduces Microsoft stake with $4.6bn donation..

16-Aug, 03:40

Bill Gates has given away $4.6bn (?3.6bn) to charity in his largest...

Bath murder: Two charged after death of Tashan Corpe

Bath murder: Two charged after death of Tashan Corpe..

16-Aug, 03:10

Two people have been charged after a man was stabbed to death in his...

Love Island’s Olivia Attwood 'fakes' cosy night in with boyfriend Chris Hughes and plastic doll Cash Hughes?

Love Island’s Olivia Attwood 'fakes' cosy night in with boyfriend Chris Hughes and plastic..

16-Aug, 10:00

The pair are both clad in onesies, with Olivia hinting that they were...

Cartoonist illustrates Trump tweets, book hits Amazon top 10

Cartoonist illustrates Trump tweets, book hits Amazon top 10..

15-Aug, 22:30

A cartoonist hoping to provide a better understanding of “the mind we...

Saudi Arabia and UAE pledge $100M to women's fund Ivanka Trump supports

Saudi Arabia and UAE pledge $100M to women's fund Ivanka Trump supports..

22-May, 18:56

Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates have pledged to give a total of...

Romanian court rules release of woman wanted in Turkey

Romanian court rules release of woman wanted in Turkey..

25-Jul, 05:40

Romania's Supreme Court has upheld a decision to release from custody a...

'This is a democracy': Int'l court may be next for Duterte

'This is a democracy': Int'l court may be next for Duterte..

16-May, 01:39

Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte acknowledged Tuesday that...

Dutch to try suspects in Malaysia flight downed in Ukraine

Dutch to try suspects in Malaysia flight downed in Ukraine..

05-Jul, 04:24

The Dutch government says any suspects in the downing of Malaysia...