Social media giants 'shamefully far' from tackling illegal content

Social media giants 'shamefully far' from tackling illegal content

Social media firms are "shamefully far" from tackling illegal and dangerous content, says a parliamentary report.

Hate speech, terror recruitment videos and sexual images of children all took too long to be removed, said the Home Affairs Select Committee report.

It called for a review of UK laws and stronger enforcement around illegal material.

And the government should consider making the sites pay to help police what people post, it said.

The cross-party committee took evidence from Facebook, Twitter and Google, the parent company of YouTube, for its report.


It said they had made efforts to tackle abuse and extremism on their platforms, but "nowhere near enough is being done".

The committee said it had found "repeated examples of social media companies failing to remove illegal content when asked to do so", including terrorist recruitment material, promotion of sexual abuse of children and incitement to racial hatred.

It said the largest firms were "big enough, rich enough and clever enough" to sort the problem out, and that it was "shameful" that they had failed to use the same ingenuity to protect public safety as they had to protect their own income.

The MPs said it was "unacceptable" that social media companies relied on users to report content, saying they were "outsourcing" the role "at zero expense".

Yet the companies expected the police - funded by the taxpayer - to bear the costs of keeping them clean of extremism.

The report's recommendations include:

"Social media companies' failure to deal with illegal and dangerous material online is a disgrace," said committee chairwoman Yvette Cooper.

"They have been asked repeatedly to come up with better systems to remove illegal material such as terrorist recruitment or online child abuse.

"Yet repeatedly, they have failed to do so. It is shameful."

Social media giants 'shamefully far' from tackling illegal content

Ms Cooper said the committee's inquiry into hate crime more broadly was curtailed when the general election was called and their recommendations had to be limited to dealing with social media companies and online hate.

Home Secretary Amber Rudd said she expected to see social media companies take "early and effective action" and promised to study the committee's recommendations.

Facebook, Twitter and Google did not respond to a BBC request for comment on the committee's findings.

The firms had previously told the committee that they worked hard to make sure freedom of expression was protected within the law.

Last week, the NSPCC called for fines for social networks which failed to protect children.

NSPCC chief executive Peter Wanless said social media sites should face penalties if children saw inappropriate material.

He also said the government should consider age-rating sites in the same way as the British Board of Film Classification rates films.

Internet companies' voluntary regulations on child protection were "not up to scratch" , he said.

"Online safety is one of the biggest risks facing children and young people today and one which the government of the day needs to tackle head on," he added.



Add Comment

all comments

  Other news

more
How the cortex assigns credit for causality

How the cortex assigns credit for causality..

28-Jun, 11:06

When you do something right, you can't learn anything from your success...

Camber Sands: 'Increase in non-British visitors' to deaths beach

Camber Sands: 'Increase in non-British visitors' to deaths beach..

28-Jun, 16:02

The changing demographics of visitors to Camber Sands in the years before...

Liam Payne shares FIRST ever picture of his son Bear Payne – three months after Cheryl gives birth

Liam Payne shares FIRST ever picture of his son Bear Payne – three months after Cheryl gives..

28-Jun, 10:42

Taking to Instagram, the One Direction star shared a sweet picture to his...

Under-screen fingerprint sensor unveiled

Under-screen fingerprint sensor unveiled..

28-Jun, 12:24

Qualcomm has announced a fingerprint ID sensor designed to be fitted...

Senior US diplomats driven to dissent, resign under President Trump

Senior US diplomats driven to dissent, resign under President Trump..

06-Jun, 10:37

The No. 2 official at the U.S. Embassy in Beijing has resigned his post...

Obamacare favorability nears record propelled by independents: poll

Obamacare favorability nears record propelled by independents: poll..

24-Feb, 03:04

A new poll gauging the public's feelings on the ongoing battle over...

What's next for refugees who want to come to the US

What's next for refugees who want to come to the US..

06-Mar, 16:59

Donald Trump's new executive order on immigration and travel includes a...

Fox News sets a new late-afternoon show

Fox News sets a new late-afternoon show..

28-Apr, 19:30

Fox News Channel is replacing its late-afternoon program "The Five" with...