Supreme Court upholds offensive trademarks as form of free speech

Supreme Court upholds offensive trademarks as form of free speech

The Slants, an Asian-American dance rock band, challenged the denial of its federal trademark registration.

Supreme Court upholds offensive trademarks as form of free speech

The Supreme Court's ruling on trademarks could end a long battle over the name of the Washington Redskins.

The Slants went to court after being denied trademark registration for a name they chose as an act of "reappropriation" — adopting a term used by others to disparage Asian Americans and wearing it as a badge of pride.

After losing in a lower court, the band won at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, which ruled 9-3 last year that "the First Amendment protects even hurtful speech." The Obama administration then appealed to the Supreme Court.

During oral argument in January, several justices said provocative names are chosen by individuals and organizations to express their views or as advertising. Denying trademark registration, they said, was a form of viewpoint discrimination.

But some justices also wondered whether the government should retain wiggle room, particularly since even without being registered, groups such as The Slants can advertise and sign contracts.

The Supreme Court has upheld negative speech in recent years, even when it involved distasteful protests at military funerals or disgusting "animal crush" videos. But last year, it allowed Texas to ban specialty license plates featuring the Confederate flag because it was considered a form of government speech.

The Slants won support during their court fight from both liberal and conservative groups, ranging from the American Civil Liberties Union to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.



Add Comment

all comments

  Other news

more
Blistering Southwest heat wave easing, but winds fan wildfires

Blistering Southwest heat wave easing, but winds fan wildfires..

25-Jun, 15:36

Men jog along the consolidated canal at sunset, Thursday, June 22, 2017,...

Perrie Edwards HITS BACK at Instagram trolls who claimed she had 'Photoshopped' her peachy behind while holidaying with Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain

Perrie Edwards HITS BACK at Instagram trolls who claimed she had 'Photoshopped' her peachy..

25-Jun, 07:57

Perrie Edwards has clapped back to Instagram trolls who accused her of...

Cross placed on lost grave of concentration camp survivor

Cross placed on lost grave of concentration camp survivor..

25-Jun, 12:12

The grave of a Nazi concentration camp survivor which was unmarked for...

Stella McCartney proud of her Beatle dad's song

Stella McCartney proud of her Beatle dad's song..

25-Jun, 09:36

Fashion designer Stella McCartney has chosen her dad's song Blackbird as...

'This Week' Transcript 3-5-17: Sarah Huckabee Sanders, Josh Earnest, and Sen. Al Franken

'This Week' Transcript 3-5-17: Sarah Huckabee Sanders, Josh Earnest, and Sen. Al Franken..

05-Mar, 09:46

THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT FOR 'THIS WEEK' on March 5, 2017 and it will be...

ABC News says 3 of its Twitter accounts were hacked

ABC News says 3 of its Twitter accounts were hacked..

23-Mar, 09:18

ABC News says three of its Twitter accounts were hacked Thursday morning...

Delphi, Transdev to partner on self-driving buses

Delphi, Transdev to partner on self-driving buses..

07-Jun, 07:30

Auto supplier Delphi is partnering with French transport company Transdev...

Paris police warn people to avoid Champs Elysees area; French media report 2 police shot

Paris police warn people to avoid Champs Elysees area; French media report 2 police shot..

20-Apr, 15:32

Paris police warn people to avoid Champs Elysees area; French media...