Why Comparing Bitcoin with Centralized Systems Based on Transaction Rate is Wrong

Why Comparing Bitcoin with Centralized Systems Based on Transaction Rate is Wrong

On the Bitcoin network, whether it is a transaction worth $100 or $1 million, it costs the same miners fee to process the payment.

On October 16, a $194 million payment was moved on the Bitcoin network with a mere $0.1 fee nearly instantaneously. Through legacy banking systems, weeks of paperwork, days of settlement system, and a significant load of compliance work is required to clear a payment of that size.

The research of Nic Carter, a Partner at Castle Island Ventures and the co-founder of Coinmetrics.io, found that comparing Bitcoin to other cryptocurrencies and centralized systems like PayPal based on transactions per second (TPS) is inaccurate.

Why Bitcoin Comparison isnt All That Simple

As shown by the chart below created by Carter, centralized systems like credit card network operators and Bitcoin target a different market. While credit and debit card network operators mostly focus on processing small payments at a large capacity, the users of Bitcoin tend to rely on the network for larger payments.


Bitcoin transactions tend to be quite large. Its hard to know the precise number, but your average transaction will be in the thousands of dollars, possibly tens of thousands. Your median transaction is well over $100, Carter explained.

Multi-million dollar payments are quite frequently moved on the Bitcoin blockchain network, and on some occasions, as seen in the $194 million BTC payment processed last month, large net-worth investors settle substantially large payments that are rarely settled using credit cards.

In November 2015, Chinese billionaire Liu Yiqian purchased a painting worth $170 million with his American Express credit card. That is, a payment $24 million smaller than the BTC transaction settled last month. Yet, due to the rarity of the transaction, the $170 million credit card purchase was reported by mainstream media outlets and national television networks, because it is not normal for an average credit card user to purchase anything larger than $10,000 to $100,000.

Based on one metric that is TPS, Bitcoin could seem like an inferior network to centralized protocols. But, Bitcoin can process significantly large payments on the network with relative ease, which centralized systems simply cannot do due to compliance and regulatory requirements.

TPS is Not the Only Measurement

While TPS can be used as a measurement, it is one of many measurements that can be utilized to evaluate and compare payment networks.

Carter noted:

Featured Image from Shutterstock

12.11.2018 / 19:10 11
SETL Granted License to Run Blockchain in Europes Securities Settlement System SETL Granted License to Run Blockchain
U.K.-based startup SETL was granted alicense from the Autorit? des March?s Financiers, the French financial watchdog, to run a blockchain-powered
$194 Million was Moved Using Bitcoin With $0.1 Fee, True Potential of Crypto $194 Million was Moved Using Bitcoin
On October 16, a Bitcoin user moved 29,999 BTC worth $194 million with a $0.1 fee, a transaction which with banks would cost tens of thousands of
Verge (XVG) And Tron (TRX) Partner, PornHub, Gears Up Crypto Payment With PumaPay Verge (XVG) And Tron (TRX) Partner,
In its bid to smoothen recurring transactions, PornHub has partnered PumaPay, an open source cryptocurrency payment option provider dedicated towards
Study Provides an Interesting Look at Changing Bitcoin Narratives Study Provides an Interesting Look at
Last week Nic Carter, the partner at Castle Island Ventures and co-founder of Coinmetrics.io, published an interesting study that looks at the
Only 33% of Bitcoin Payments Used to Purchase Goods, Economic Value in Question Only 33% of Bitcoin Payments Used to
As global investors flock to cryptocurrency as an investment vehicle, the use of cryptocurrencies for their intended purposes has come into question.
PayPals Ever Increasing Fees Will Push Users to Cryptocurrency PayPals Ever Increasing Fees Will Push
PayPal was an innovator in digital payment services but as they introduce a new, costlierfee structure more people may find using Bitcoin and
Comments (0)
Add a comment
Comment on