Israeli Regulator: Utility Tokens Shouldn't Be Deemed Securities

Israeli Regulator: Utility Tokens Shouldn't Be Deemed Securities

The Israel Securities Authority is recommending lenient regulations for initial coin offerings, including a clear definition of what separates a so-called "utility token" from a security.

In a report released last week, the regulator even proposed a temporary sandbox, where regulators would allow entrepreneurs to experiment under supervision as the cryptocurrency market evolves.

According to the ISA report, a utility token that "confers usage rights in a product or service offered by a specific venture" shouldn't necessarily be deemed a security. Neither should tokens that are used solely for clearing, exchange or payments for a specific project, the report said.

Many blockchain advocates welcomed the Israeli regulator's stance. Amitay Molko, co-founder of the Jerusalem-based networking group Blockchain JLM, told CoinDesk:

"The Israeli regulators are showing that they are taking this very seriously and fairly. This is the first step in the right direction."

However, a utility token mightbe a security if the cryptocurrency isn't controlled by a cohesive party, such as the startup itself, and if it can be used for payments beyond the initial venture.

For example, if someone tried to fundraise for a private company by issuing a new general-purpose cryptocurrency similar tobitcoin, that might be a security token, in the agency's view.

Case by case

The report recommends evaluating new tokens on a case-by-case basis, saying:

"A cryptocurrency shall be considered a security according to the array of circumstances and characteristics of each case, taking into consideration the purpose of the law. Cryptocurrencies conferring rights similar to those of conventional securities, such as shares, bonds, or participation units, shall be considered securities."

In the meantime, the ISA report defined a security or investment token as a cryptocurrency entitling the holder to the future cash flow or "ownership rights, participation, or membership in a specific venture," according to a translation by the Israeli outlet Globes.

The clearest distinction between a utility token and a security, according to the report, is whether there are options to trade it in a secondary market. Another crucial factor is whether there is an existing platform where people can actually use the tokens. Promising a future platform doesn't guarantee the token was purchased for its utility.

If there's no working platform or use case, despite trading options, Israeli regulators believe the token was probably purchased as an investment.

The report is now in the hands of ISA chair Anat Guetta, who will decide how to proceed with unique securities regulations for the cryptocurrency space.

The Israeli agency's stance stands in contrast to other regulators, such as the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, whose chairman, Jay Clayton, recently said every ICO he's seen was a security.

Israeli shekel image via Shutterstock

19.03.2018 / 13:19 21
Israeli Crypto Companies Banned From Stock Exchange Indices Israeli Crypto Companies Banned From
In a bid to reduce systemic risk, the Israel Securities Authority has announced that it will not include companies operating in the cryptocurrency
Second Securities Regulator Halts 'Black Cell' Token Sale Second Securities Regulator Halts
Hong Kong's Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) has halted an initial coin offering (ICO) on the grounds that the issuer was selling securities
Israel: Steps Toward Cryptocurrency Support? Israel: Steps Toward Cryptocurrency
An analysis of the Blockchain industry in Israel. The views expressed here are the authors own and do not necessarily represent the views of
Israel Bars Crypto Firms from Tel Aviv Stock Exchange Indices Israel Bars Crypto Firms from Tel Aviv
Israel's securities regulator has said that cryptocurrency-related firms may not be listed on theTel Aviv Stock Exchange (TASE) indices. According
South Korea Regulators Considering Reversal of ICO Ban: Report South Korea Regulators Considering
Nearly six months after a blanket ban on ICO (initial coin offering) fundraising, South Korean regulators are reportedly planning to allow ICOs,
Brazil Regulators Move to Block Bitcoin Mining Investments Brazil Regulators Move to Block Bitcoin
Brazil's Securities and Exchange Commission (CVM) has moved to suspend the offer of securities relatedto a local bitcoin mining operation. In a
Comments (0)
Add a comment
Comment on